Collector Mentality, Part One: I Must Have Everything!

When I initially started this post, it was to wonder about the need to collect every variant possible – but as I was writing I came to a realization regarding that need, and the post began to morph into something else. It became a stream of consciousness musing about the different collector mentalities. This first part is entitled I Must Have Everything! Parts two and three are also currently written, so expect those in the not too distant future. 


I’m assuming three things of you if you’re reading this.

1) You read comics.
2) You have at least a partial physical collection of comics, whether you read primarily physical or digital.
3) You’re at least partially aware of variant covers.

asm hal.jpgAlright, so let me be the first to say that I’ve been known to go after a certain variant cover if the artwork speaks to me more than the standard cover but it’s rare for me to get more than one cover of a comic, although there are a handful of exceptions to that statement; I have both the regular cover and a sketch cover of Extraordinary X-Men (complete with a Nick Bradshaw Wolverine sketch), two different covers of Amazing Spider-Man #1 (the one after Superior) because a local shop had a variant… and that’s about it unless you count the issues I brought twice without paying attention to the numbering… but that’s stupidity on my end rather than a desire to buy multiple copies of a comic. I’ve always brought a comic to read first and foremost, and to collect as secondary motivation – unless they’re an older key issue in some form or another – so I’ve never really sought to hunt down a specific cover, unless the cover art speaks to me but even that is limited to what I can see in the shop; if there’s no choice to be made then I grab the issue in front of me and go read it.

What I’m saying is that personally I don’t have the desire to have multiple copies of the same comic with different cover art in my collection. Maybe one day there will be one or two variant covers that I just have to have, regardless of whether I own a different cover because the art speaks to me in a mysterious way… although it hasn’t happened yet, you never say never, right? Although the cover art is useful in attracting your eyes to the comic when it’s on the shelf the cover has always been a secondary consideration for me when compared with the contents of the story, and while I may not be unique in that aspect, there are people who enjoy collecting every available variant cover, often spending hundreds and hundreds of dollars in the hunt for a single cover.

usavengers variants.jpg
Each of these variants to Marvel’s USAvengers comic featured a different hero from each State – 50 in all, and if you wanted them all…

When I set out to write this, I couldn’t understand that desire, that drive, the compulsive need to spend so much to acquire what is essentially multiple copies of the same comic with only the one difference – albeit a very noticeable one. Not that I would ever discourage a person from doing so if that is what makes them happy, but I could fathom why a person search out covers they may not particularly like just to be able to say they own a full set?

Wolverine_Vol_2_88.jpgIt was something that I couldn’t understand until I thought about my Wolverine collection and the words “full set,” because I’ve been slowly building a full run of Wolverine Vol. 1 & 2 over the last five years, picking up the odd issue here and there with the eventual goal to read the series in numerical order for the first time (the reprints I read were often out of sequence) so my desire to have the full set, so to speak, is pretty strong. Although one could argue that it is not yet as strong as some of the folks who want a full set of variants as I’m not willing to plunk down hundreds of dollars per issue, but I was at least able to understand where the need to collect them all comes from, even if I don’t quite get the need .

But this brings me to another question, and one I hadn’t thought of previously: does this level of collector mentality, that of collecting all the variants for a certain series or character have dangerous echoes of the time before the bursting of the last comic book speculation bubble, or is it simply a small subset of the comic book community doing what they enjoy?

Since starting this article I did take a few minutes to ask a few people from an awesome group on Facebook (that I won’t name because I don’t want to identify those to whom I spoke, even though I’m sure they wouldn’t mind) what drove them to want to collect every possible variant for a certain series. The answer, generally, was because they wanted to have a full collection of their favourite character. It was about the hunt, which is something I can utterly understand.

The difference between my collector bug and theirs is that they want everything a certain series has to offer whereas I want every issue of Wolverine Vol.2.



2 thoughts on “Collector Mentality, Part One: I Must Have Everything!

  1. I hadn’t actually read your blog until I was browsing through some of my own posts and noticed you liked one, clicked on your icon, and saw this article. As someone who sometimes tries to find variants, I figured I’d give it a read.

    I liked the article. Some nice thoughts. From my own point of view, it’s borderline OCD. And I say this as someone who does try to get the variants. it’s the same reason that when I play a platform game, like Ratchet and Clank, I love to 100% the game, collect all the hidden treasures, etc. Or when I play Final Fantasy X, try to get all the weapons, even though you don’t really need them to beat the final boss. It’s almost a compulsive need to collect all the variants so that when I finally do have Uncanny X-Men #1 all the way to #600…I can honestly say I have them all. Probably won’t ever happen, but it’s a nice pipe dream.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I think that’s why I tend to collect series that aren’t as sought after in floppy form (Wolverine Vol. 2 and Maverick are the last two I’ve been working on slowly), verses the comics I just want to read like a lot of early X-Men and Spider-Man because they’re a lot more affordable.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s